How to Get Your Business Found in ChatGPT and Other AI Search Tools

If you run a small business in Australia, you have probably heard that customers are now asking ChatGPT for recommendations instead of Googling. Maybe a mate raised it over a beer at a barbecue. Maybe an enquiry landed in your inbox that opened with "ChatGPT suggested I get in touch." Either way, you are wondering whether this is a real shift or just the next thing marketers want to sell you.

Here is our honest position, and we will say it plainly before the explaining starts. AI search is not a brand new channel you have to learn from scratch. It rewards the same things a good local reputation always has: being clear about what you do, being consistent everywhere you appear, and being genuinely trusted by other people. What has changed is that the payoff is now binary. You are either in the answer or you are not. This guide explains what that means in practice, with no hype and no jargon, from a team that sits with business owners every week and helps them get found.

What does 'ranking in ChatGPT' actually mean for a small business?

It means being the business ChatGPT names when someone asks a question you could answer. There is no page of ten blue links. There is a conversation, and either you get a mention or you stay invisible.

Picture the old way. A homeowner in Parramatta with a burst pipe types "emergency plumber Parramatta" into Google, scans the results, clicks a few. Now a growing number of people open ChatGPT instead and type something messier and more human: "my hot water system is leaking, who should I call in Parramatta and what should I expect to pay." The reply comes back as a direct answer. Sometimes it names specific businesses. Sometimes it describes what to look for and how to choose.

So "ranking" here is not about position one versus position three. It is binary in a way Google never was. You are part of the answer, or you are not in the room. That is the shift. It is also why owners who shrugged off the early days of Google search are paying closer attention this time around.

The encouraging part is that the things making a business genuinely findable and trustworthy online are the same things that make an AI engine comfortable naming you. You do not need to learn to code. You need to understand how these tools weigh you up.

How do AI engines like ChatGPT decide which businesses to mention?

AI engines pull from a mix of their training data, live web results, and trusted third-party sources, then assemble an answer they judge to be accurate and helpful. They lean towards businesses described consistently and clearly in lots of places.

Here is the mechanism, stripped of the technical layers. When you ask ChatGPT or Google's AI Overviews a question, the model is not reaching into one tidy database labelled "best plumbers." It is drawing on patterns learned from enormous amounts of text, and increasingly it is fetching current information from the web as you ask. To decide who to surface, it weighs a few things:

• /Consistency. Does your business name, address, phone number, and description match everywhere it appears? Mismatched details make AI hesitant to cite you.
• /Corroboration. Are you mentioned by sources the model already trusts, such as Google Business Profile, established directories, review platforms, and reputable local listings?
• /Clarity of what you do. Can the model easily tell what you offer, where, and for whom? Vague websites get skipped.
• /Recency and activity. A business that looks current and active is safer to recommend than one that looks abandoned.
• /Relevance to the exact question. A physio in Fremantle who clearly mentions post-surgery rehab will be surfaced for that query far more readily than one whose site just says "we treat all conditions."

The thread running through all of it is trust and specificity. AI engines are cautious about naming a business, because getting it wrong reflects badly on them. The easier you make it to verify who you are and what you do, the happier they are to put you in front of a customer.

What is AEO and why does it matter more than you might think right now?

AEO stands for Answer Engine Optimisation. It is the practice of structuring your online presence so AI tools can understand, trust, and quote your business when answering questions. It matters now because the behaviour is shifting faster than most owners realise.

Think of AEO as the natural next step after SEO. Search Engine Optimisation helped Google rank your pages. Answer Engine Optimisation helps answer engines like ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google's AI Overviews, and Microsoft Copilot pick you as part of their reply. The skills overlap. The emphasis changes. SEO often rewarded volume and keywords. AEO rewards clarity, structure, and real authority.

Why now, rather than in a few years? Because the early movers are setting the patterns these models learn from. When an accountant in Brunswick gets quoted today as a clear, trustworthy source on small business tax in Victoria, that association compounds. The businesses building this presence now are laying foundations their competitors will struggle to catch later.

We go deeper into the practical mechanics on our SEO, AEO and GEO services page, but the core idea is simple. Be the clearest, most trustworthy, most specific answer to the questions your customers actually ask.

The five things you can do this week to improve your chances of being cited

You can make real progress in a few hours without hiring anyone. The five highest-impact moves are tightening your listings, writing clear service pages, answering real customer questions, gathering reviews, and adding structured information to your site.

Here is exactly what each one involves:

1. /Tighten every business listing you have. Make sure your Google Business Profile, Bing Places, and any industry directories show the exact same name, address, phone number, and description. Inconsistency is the single most common reason AI tools avoid naming a business. We see it constantly: an old suite number on one listing, a mobile on another.
2. /Write service pages that say what you actually do. Replace "quality service you can trust" with specifics. A physio in Fremantle should have a clear page on post-surgery rehab, another on sports injuries, and so on. Specificity is what gets surfaced.
3. /Answer the real questions customers ask. Write content that responds directly to things like "how much does a blocked drain cost to fix in Sydney" or "do I need a BAS agent or an accountant." Lead with the answer, then explain. AI engines favour content shaped like an answer.
4. /Build genuine reviews. Encourage happy customers to leave honest reviews on Google and the platforms that matter in your trade. Reviews are a trust signal AI tools weigh heavily, and they describe you in real customer language.
5. /Add structured data to your website. This is Schema.org markup that tells search and AI engines exactly what your business is, where it operates, and what you offer. If that sounds technical, it is the one item here where help pays off quickly, and you can start with a free AI search audit.

Do these five things and you are already ahead of the vast majority of Australian small businesses, most of whom have done nothing at all yet.

Does your Google ranking still matter if someone is asking ChatGPT instead?

Yes, very much. Your Google presence is one of the main sources AI engines draw on to decide whether to trust and mention you, so strong traditional search feeds directly into AI visibility.

This is the bit a lot of people miss. AI search and traditional search are not two worlds at war. They are wired together. When ChatGPT fetches live information, it is often pulling from the same web Google indexes. Google's AI Overviews sit directly on top of its search results. A business that ranks well, has a clear website, and shows up consistently across the web is feeding good signals into both systems at once.

So the worst move would be abandoning your Google efforts because you heard SEO is dead. It is not dead. It is the foundation AEO is built on. Keep your traditional search house in order and layer AEO on top. They reinforce each other.

The one real shift worth understanding is the goal. Pure traffic is becoming less reliable as AI answers more questions on the page. Being cited and recommended is the new prize. We write more about that balance across our blog.

What kinds of businesses are most likely to benefit from AI search visibility?

Local service businesses, professional services, and anyone solving a specific problem customers research before buying stand to gain the most. If people ask questions before they choose you, AI search matters to you.

In practice, the clearest winners include:

• /Local trades and services. Plumbers, electricians, builders, cleaners. People constantly ask AI tools for local recommendations and what a job should cost.
• /Professional services. Accountants, lawyers, financial advisers, consultants. These are research-heavy decisions where people ask AI to explain options and suggest who to talk to.
• /Health and allied health. Physios, dentists, psychologists, clinics. Patients ask detailed questions about conditions and treatments, often before they ever open a booking tool like HotDoc.
• /Specialist retailers and suppliers. Businesses with deep product knowledge customers want explained before they buy.
• /B2B service providers. Agencies, IT support, equipment suppliers whose buyers do serious homework.

The common thread is a considered decision. If someone buys on impulse with no research, AI search matters less. If they ask questions first, weigh up options, and want to feel confident before they commit, being part of the AI answer is becoming essential.

Common mistakes Australian SMBs make when trying to optimise for AI answers

The biggest mistakes are stuffing keywords, faking expertise, neglecting consistency, and treating AI optimisation as a one-off task. Each one quietly chips away at the trust these engines are looking for.

Here are the errors we see most when we sit down with new clients:

• /Keyword stuffing like it is 2010. Cramming "emergency plumber Parramatta Sydney NSW best cheap" into every sentence does nothing. Modern engines read for meaning, and this reads as spam.
• /Claiming expertise you cannot back up. "Award-winning" or "Australia's number one" with nothing behind it. AI engines check claims against other sources. Empty ones get ignored, or worse, they erode trust.
• /Inconsistent business details. A slightly different address on Facebook than on Google. An old phone number lingering in a directory. Small mismatches do real damage.
• /Thin, generic content. A homepage that could belong to any business in your trade gives AI nothing specific to grab.
• /Treating it as set and forget. AI search is moving quickly. The businesses that win treat this as an ongoing practice, not a box ticked once.

The pattern behind every mistake is the same. AI engines reward genuine, verifiable, specific information, and they quietly penalise anything that smells like an attempt to game them. Be real, be specific, and you sidestep nearly all of these.

How do you know if any of this is actually working?

You check whether you are being mentioned, you watch the quality of your enquiries, and you track your visibility in the tools your customers actually use. It takes a slightly different approach to the dashboards you are used to.

Traditional SEO had clean metrics like rankings and traffic. AI search is messier to measure, but here is how to get a real read:

• /Ask the tools directly. Open ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google's AI Overviews and ask the questions a customer would. Does your business come up? Done regularly, this simple test tells you a lot. I do exactly this for clients before and after we start, and the change over a few months is the clearest proof there is.
• /Listen to your enquiries. Start asking new customers how they found you. When people begin saying an AI tool pointed them your way, you are getting traction.
• /Watch referral patterns. Some AI tools now send clickable traffic. Keep an eye on referrals from sources like ChatGPT and Perplexity in your analytics.
• /Track your foundations. Gains in your Google visibility, review volume, and content clarity are leading indicators that AI visibility will follow.

Measurement here is about trends, not one perfect number. If your mentions are growing, your enquiries are improving in quality, and your foundations are getting stronger, it is working. We help clients set up proper tracking, and you can see the kinds of outcomes we aim for on our results page.

Where to start if you want expert help rather than a DIY rabbit hole

Start with an honest audit of where your business sits in AI search today, then build a plan from there. You can absolutely do the basics yourself. If you would rather not disappear down a rabbit hole, that is where we come in.

The five steps earlier will move you forward, and we genuinely want you to use them whether or not you ever contact us. But there is a point where the structured data, the ongoing monitoring, and the strategy across both traditional and AI search become a real job. That is the point where bringing in a practitioner saves you time and gets you there faster.

At Brain Buddy AI we work with Australian small and medium businesses every week, from trades to professional services, helping them get found in ChatGPT and the wider AI search landscape. We are practitioners, not theorists. We sit with the same scepticism you bring, and we earn trust by showing results.

If you want a clear picture of where you stand, get in touch with our team or grab a free AI search audit. Either way, you will walk away knowing exactly what to do next.

Frequently asked questions

How does ChatGPT decide which businesses to recommend?

ChatGPT weighs consistency, corroboration from trusted sources, clarity about what you do, how current your business looks, and how closely you match the exact question. Businesses described clearly and consistently across the web are the easiest for it to recommend.

Can a small business actually compete in AI search against big brands?

Yes. AI tools often favour specific, local, relevant answers over big generic ones. A specialist physio in Fremantle can be the recommended answer for local rehab queries even when national chains exist, because specificity and local relevance carry real weight.

Do I need to choose between SEO and AEO?

No. They reinforce each other. Strong traditional search performance feeds the signals AI engines use, while AEO builds on that foundation. The smartest approach is to keep your Google presence healthy and layer AEO on top.

About the author

Jayson Munday

Founder - AEO & SEO Strategist

20+ Years in SEO & Digital Marketing22 years in practice

Founder of Brain Buddy AI with over 20 years in search marketing. Jayson identified the AI search revolution early and built one of Australia's first managed SEO, AEO, and GEO service to help businesses get found by every AI engine.

SEOAEOGEOContent StrategyLead Generation

More from Jayson →LinkedInWebsite